
In his mammoth travel book Iberia, James Michener complained that even after regularly traveling in Spain for forty years, he'd never had a great paella. (He also said he'd never seen decent Flamenco or a good bullfight.) While I can't say I've never had good paella, I do admit: a good paella is hard to find, even in Spain.
Many non-Spaniards seem to think paella is the "national dish" of Spain. It isn't. Originally, paella was very much a regional dish (from Valencia). Andrés, my father-in-law, who was from Galicia (nearly the opposite side of the country from Valencia) regarded paella--and Valencian rice dishes in general--as an odd kind of food from the south, much as in the U.S. a New Englander might view grits.
That said, there is something like a pan-Spanish or national version of the paella, the "mixed paella"--a relatively recent invention, I suspect. This is the bright yellow-orange (usually artificially colored) rice dish cooked with chicken, chorizo, and shellfish, in a wide, shallow pan, and decorated with pimientos. According to Penelope Casas' Paella! Spectacular Rice Dishes from Spain, this "mixed paella" is not an authentic Valencian dish at all. A true Valencian, she says, keeps his paella much simpler--just seafood and rice, or just rabbit and rice, or snails and rice, and so on.
When Ana and I are in Madrid, the main places I see "mixed paella" are in restaurants at the Plaza Mayor and at the airport. This is to say, mixed paella is for tourists, and serious food people often sneer at it much the way they do at sangria.
If you want authentic Valencian (or Murcian, or Cordobés) rice dishes, it's usually necessary to go to a restaurant specializing in them, where, most likely, they will not be called "paella" at all but simply arroz (rice): arroz con calamares (rice with squid), arroz con calabacines (rice with summer squash), and so on. The rice may be cooked in a wide flat paella pan or in a deeper pan that looks a little like a flat-bottomed wok, or even in a pot. The rice may be light and fluffy or moist, risotto style, or something in between. There is a very wide variety of Spanish rice dishes.
I have nothing against the mixed paella. I can understand why it has become something of a symbol. It's pretty and festive. The colors are not only bright, they suggest the Spanish flag. The chorizo is not on my low-cholesterol diet, but I still hope to post a recipe on a good mixed paella in the future.
My main problem with paellas, authentic and not, is that the seafood in them is almost always overcooked. The traditional way of cooking paella--cooking fish and shellfish together with the rice--is to blame. Spanish rice takes twenty minutes to cook, and it then needs a ten minute rest before serving. So any fish or shellfish you add will cook at least half an hour. In most cases this is way, way too long.
My brother-in-law Antonio once told me that a true paella aficionado would not care about overcooked shellfish. For him, it's the flavor of the rice that matters. Personally, I would much rather cook the paella in such a way that both the rice and the seafood come out just right, even if it means resorting to less-than-authentic techniques.
My approach to seafood paella is simple. I simmer clams, mussels, shrimp, and other shellfish separately until each is just barely done. (The one exception is the squid, which needs longer cooking anyway, and so is cooked with the rice). I reserve the simmering liquid as the broth base for the paella. When the rice is cooked, I decorate it with the seafood. The ten minute "rest" after cooking is a good time to do this. The heat of the rice warms the shellfish through.
This way, the rice comes out flavorful, and the shellfish and fish are cooked perfectly.
A Recipe for Seafood Paella (arroz a la marinera, o arroz pescador)
Ingredients:
1 cup of Spanish rice (Calasparra, Bomba, a paella rice such as La Marjal, or Italian arborio)
***Note: the rice is important! Read my posts on Spanish rice dishes for more info on rice)***
1/4 cup olive oil
1 teaspoon of pimentón (see my post on pimentón)
a dozen shrimp (for this post, I used Florida rock shrimp), with shells on. With heads on, they're even better
a dozen littleneck clams
a dozen mussels
2 medium squid, sliced into 1/4" thick rings
a small pinch of saffron, ground with a little salt in a mortar
1 onion, chopped
1 medium tomato, chopped
1/2 cup of English peas
2 cloves of garlic
3-4 cups of water
chopped parsley
1/4 cup of flame-roasted red peppers, cut into slivers (see my post on flame-roasted red peppers), or piquillo peppers
2 bay leaves
a slice of lemon with peel
a dozen peppercorns
Clean the shellfish. Soak the clams in water for an hour or two. Scrub them. Scrub the mussels and pluck out the beards with tweezers.
Meanwhile, heat up about 3 cups of water in a large pot. Add the bay leaves, whole peppercorns, and the lemon slice. Let the spices barely simmer in the water while you're cleaning the shellfish.
To cook the shellfish, work in batches. I like to start with the clams because they add salt to the broth (and usually all the salt that's needed for the paella). Add the clams to the simmering liquid and cover the pot. Check on them after five minutes. Remove any that have opened and put them on a plate. Continue steaming 3 to 4 minutes more until all the clams have opened. Throw away any that don't.
Steam the mussels in the exactly the same way, removing them from the pot as they open.
Now steam the shrimp. For medium-large shrimp, this usually only takes 3-4 minutes. Don't overcook them.
Strain the broth through several layers of cheesecloth and reserve.
Reserve all the steamed shellfish.
In a large heavy skillet or a small paella pan, fry the chopped onion in the olive oil until it's soft and translucent. Add the chopped tomato, chopped garlic, and about a tablespoon of chopped parsley. Add the sliced squid. Cook for three of four minutes, stirring.
Add the saffron. Add the pimentón.
Add the rice and stir. Let the rice "fry" three or four minutes. Keep stirring.
Add the peas and the strained broth. Give the paella another stir, but don't stir any more after that.
Let the paella simmer, uncovered, over medium heat, for 20 minutes. Around the fifteenth minute, you may want to check the rice at the bottom of the pan to make sure it isn't burning. Just insert a wooden spoon and peek. You want a crust to form on the bottom, but if it looks like it may burn, add a little more broth or water.
After twenty minutes, remove the paella from the burner and let it rest ten minutes. While it's resting, decorate the top with the steamed seafood, flame roasted peppers, and fresh chopped parsley.